23rd January
latest news: Anna's sweet and sticky pork buns

Blog Sections

That Girl
Roxy

Latest blog entries

candle

The Advent Calendar: Day 3

Sunday, 4th December 2011

That Girl from Derwent dwells on the value of religion this Christmas.

Student reading

A dividing line

Sunday, 6th November 2011

That Girl from Derwent has learned a few more things about prejudice since moving up North.

Stamp out racism

There's no need to be racist

Monday, 31st October 2011

That Girl From Derwent reckons if you're going to be offensive, you should find a better reason.

Fuck off, Amerika

The problem of "swearing"

Tuesday, 25th October 2011

That Girl from Derwent considers why it is that some words have wider implications than others.

More blog entries

Coots at York Uni
york minster
SlutWalk2
Art class
Easter eggs
A pile of open books
girl glasses

Hey, stupid.

Sat, 16th Apr 11
Older man

Older and wiser

Sun, 10th Apr 11
Naughty Food

Once upon a time I was falling in love

Bonnie Tyler
Really rocking that 80's hair!
Thursday, 9th December 2010
So it’s December, and the completely random and arbitrary ban on Christmas music that all my friends have imposed on me has thankfully been lifted. Great! Except...I don’t want to listen to Christmas music. There’s enough of it in the shops already, and on my last visit to Willow there was a massive, half-crazed attempt at ‘jiving’ to Mariah Carey’s ‘All I Want For Christmas Is You’. Complete with faux-snow. Like most things in the Willow, it wasn’t very pretty.

But anyway, yes it’s a bit weird. There’s really only been one song that has been on repeat on my ipod over the few days of apocalyptic, snowy weather – Bonnie Tyler’s classic 1983 hit ‘Total Eclipse of the Heart’. Okay, so maybe it’s got something to do with my friend’s constant singing of it during a pub lunch after yet another lecture on James Joyce. Apparently it’s some kind of sports anthem now. The real reason, however, is quite simple. I just love the song so much.

I first heard ‘Total Eclipse of the Heart’ at the age of six. My dad had just got a new company car and it came with a CD player (as opposed to the cassette tapes which I was used to). Bonnie Tyler was track #13 or something on a love songs compilation thing that I found in the glove compartment. Mundanely, I didn’t fall in love immediately. No, I had to wait nearly ten years, when I was undergoing an ironic hipster phase. I say this rather shame-facedly, because of how utterly silly it all was. I wanted to be the cool anti-cool kid, the bloke who proclaimed his cultural superiority over others through copious watching of French films he didn’t understand and through listening to stuff no one else was listening to. Thus, this translated not only into an appreciation for things like Neutral Milk Hotel, but also for a lot of naff, cheesy dance-pop. A lot of the kids at school were into things like Linkin Park because they had loads of guitars and angst, and I consciously listened to things that were the direct opposite. And so it was that I discovered Nicki French’s Euro-dance cover of ‘Total Eclipse of the Heart’, playing on the radio one day. It was a perfect symbol of my one-man resistance against conformity. If I could have had an annoying ‘ironic’ haircut I would have got one, except my school didn’t allow it.

Looking back, I’m lucky to have left school with any friends at all.

Of course, later I grew up and discovered that in my little bourgeois bubble I was rebelling against nothing, that I was in fact quite privileged, and making mix CDs featuring Kylie, the Smiths and Argentine rock group Attaque 77 all at once and foisting them onto my unsuspecting friends didn’t make me cooler than the next guy, it just made me look a bit sad. And so I learned to lighten up, stopped being a prat and began enjoying music for reasons other than being part of some kind of imaginary cultural hierarchy.

Nonetheless, despite these epiphanies, ‘Total Eclipse of the Heart’ remained strong in my heart, perhaps even more so than before. I’d moved past Nicki French by this stage and learned to love the original, with Tyler’s throaty wail and Bruce Springsteen’s bandmates producing the loudest, most bombastic sound possible behind her. I think my favourite bit is right after the first chorus when Max Weinberg’s drums kick in for the instrumental break. I don’t know what the technical drum term is, nor do I care, but it’s a massive sound, like a cannonball. Or indeed, the explosion of the powder keg that had hitherto been giving off sparks.

Either way it’s a song that I have both laughingly sung along to with friends and, rather embarrassingly, one that I’ve played after I’ve had my heart broken. It’s a song with so many associations for me, both joyous and painful, and I can’t think of any other piece of music that is more fitting to soundtrack the beauty, sadness, laughter, and even this incomparably crappy cold caused by the snowfall.

Check out The Yorker's Twitter account for all the latest news Go to The Yorker's Fan Page on Facebook
#1 Greg Ebdon
Thu, 9th Dec 2010 9:53am

Fantastic article, brilliantly written.

"And so I learned to lighten up, stopped being a prat and began enjoying music for reasons other than being part of some kind of imaginary cultural hierarchy." Can I get you to have a conversation with some of my hipster 'friends'?

#2 Cieran Douglass
Thu, 9th Dec 2010 3:20pm

Though you've doubtless already seen it, I share this for the benefit of everyone else - the literal video version
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj-x9ygQEGA

Add Comment

You must log in to submit a comment.