23rd January
latest news: Anna's sweet and sticky pork buns

latest news

App Challenge Logo

Photo Diary app wins York prize

Friday, 20th January 2012

A group of York students has won the opportunity to have their very own I-phone application developed after winning The App Challenge final, held at the Ron Cooke Hub on Wednesday, January 18.

computer

Students warned about loans scam

Thursday, 19th January 2012

YUSU Welfare officer Bob Hughes has warned students to be vigilant after a student loans phishing scam has been revealed.

Her Most Gracious Majesty

Queen Comes to York

Wednesday, 18th January 2012

Her Majesty the Queen will be visiting York on Maundy Thursday, 5th April, as part of the 800th anniversary of York’s Charter for the traditional “Royal Maundy” ceremony.

Berrick Saul

Flooding Triggers Network Outage On Eve Of Exams

Saturday, 14th January 2012

A flood caused by a heating system “failure” forced the university IT services to shut down many essential systems on Sunday night, causing problems for many students on the eve of their exams and assignment due-dates.

more news

Red Phone
King's Manor
Aimee and Kevin the Cow
Bomb Disposal Unit
Central Hall & North side of the lake
King's Manor
The Yorker Logo
christmas
Central Hall & North side of the lake

UGM Result: Grace out by 8 votes

UGM
UGM Results
Thursday, 7th February 2008

Grace Fletcher-Hackwood has been voted out of her position by only 8 votes.

1440 votes were cast, an unprecedented total for a Union General Meeting (UGM) vote.

The vote passed by just a 0.5% majority.

The results were announced to campus press at 12.40pm, and YUSU have announced: "YUSU are able to announce that the motion has passed and that Grace will leave her position with immediate effect."

Quote I'm delighted by the result, I think the students have spoken. Quote
Dan Taylor

The unprecedented step leaves YUSU without a welfare representative, until either Fletcher-Hackwood launches an appeal, or a replacement is found.

The likely replacement would be the Academic and Welfare Officer-elect, who would not be voted in until Week 9 during the YUSU Elections.

Quote The students have spoken on this one, though the result was very, very close. Quote
Anne-Marie Canning

Should Fletcher-Hackwood wish to appeal, she would have to call an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM.)

Dan Taylor, who proposed the motion, and was the student involved in the incident told The Yorker: "I'm delighted by the result, I think the students have spoken and I thank Grace for the work she has done in the past but this incident has impaired her abilities to do the job in the future."

Fletcher-Hackwood spoke on her 'Your:Support' radio show on URY and said: "The no confidence vote was put through by a student who has made it one of his missions at university to... well, perhaps to destroy me is too strong a way of putting it. But Dan wanted me out of this job and he has succeeded."

She also revealed that she hadn't yet decided whether or not to appeal but added: "I'm grateful for the amount of support I've had."

Quote Grace will leave her position with immediate effect. Quote
YUSU Press Release

Anne-Marie Canning, YUSU President, said: “The students have spoken on this one, though the result was very, very close. The outcome does worry me, because we’re now without an Academic & Welfare Officer and aren’t likely to have the job covered until July."

Canning added: "However, we’re confident that we can make sure that students don’t lose out – it’s just going to mean more pressure on Union Officers and staff."

Should Fletcher-Hackwood successfully appeal, the alternative motion to censure Fletcher-Hackwood, which received 688 votes 'For' whilst 488 voted 'Against', would stand instead. It would result in her being disciplined, but would allow her to retain her post.

All other motions passed, including a controversial decision to make Women's Committee 'Open to all'.

Those requiring Welfare support should contact Mel Nichol, Academic and Welfare Co-ordinator on mjn500@york.ac.uk or at her office in the YUSU building.

Check out The Yorker's Twitter account for all the latest news Go to The Yorker's Fan Page on Facebook
Showing 21 - 40 of 63 comments
#21 Dan Taylor
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 12:38am

Mrs Fletcher-Hall,

Indeed I am familiar with Ghandi- one of my own quotes came from the chaps mouth: "be the change you wish to see in the world". That could be applied to this incident really, could it not?

Just to enlighten you on the apology I received from Grace. It was prompted by me in a facebook message- not her. Her public apology was frankly embarassing for her; claiming that she was sorry but the fact she was a "5ft 5 midget" and me a "strapping" individual made it somehow legitimate. Next time a man comes into her office and says he is being hit by his 5ft wife, will Grace react the same? Before this incident, I would have said no. Now, I have genuine concerns that she may not.

I am delighted to hear that your daughter comes from a family of strong women. Two things I was taught as a kid, just for your interest were 1) that apologising is always unconditional and to someones face (not by facebook messages or through media channels with silly excuses) and 2) that if you do wrong, there will be no-one to bail yourself out and as a result you should take responsibility for your actions. Grace did neither.

The integeral side of Grace should have resulted in her resigning. It did not. Instead, the students of this institution have spoken and that is that. Finito.

I have no personal victory in this- democracy is the true victory with 1440 people voting. They have spoken. Oh, how unpopular democrary becomes when those who advocate it the most see the wrong side of it.

Dan Taylor

#22 Dan Taylor
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 12:41am

About bloody time!! Well done Dan and all of us who supported the motion! How can someone stay when they hit another student from her position! LUDICROUS!

Comment Deleted comment deleted by a moderator
Comment Deleted comment deleted by a moderator
#25 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 12:54am
  1. 19 - very little in the world is binary. And of course, had it been 0.5% in favour of Grace staying, it would still not be "pretty clear".
#26
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 12:57am

Dan,
I don't wish to enter into correspondance with you, but it aint over till the differently weighted female bursts into chorus!

#27 Dan Taylor
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 1:00am

Sorry forgive me for maybe missing something, but you begun this correspondance with me. I have no interest in justifying the student response to someone with a clear personal interest in this matter. I think the "differently weighted female's" cause is being done little good by her mother posting on a student paper website trying to emotionally blakmail students who made a considered decision on the future of their A&W Rep, just as Grace did at the UGM.

#28
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 1:17am

It's called humour, Dan! I forgot you were Southern!

#29
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 1:29am

OK...thanks very much for your support, Mom, but this is now getting pretty weird, so both of you, leave it. Thanks x

Grace

#30 Dan Taylor
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 1:36am

I agree with Grace. Mudslinging stops. The judgement has been passed and I will from now on be offering no more comment on the matter. It is descending into a comeplete farce otherwise and makes both sides look like idiots (the first name-calling I have used...).

Dan Taylor

#31 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 2:06am

You wouldn't want to cross Mrs F-H, would you? Atta-girl. Wherever you end up, Dan, she'll be watching...

#32 Myles Preston
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 2:35am

I'd like to hear from John Lewis on this matter.

#33 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 2:58am

John Lewis' Office has offered this statement on the matter: 100101110100101011101010

#34 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 5:35am

I think it's admirable to see the support from Grace's mum, and she should be treated with respect not smartarse comments. She is also right; what goes around, comes around and I honestly hope that Dan Taylor gets what is coming to him for launching what was essentially a smear campaign. It will be a long way to fall; off his pedestal on top of the moral high ground. The decision today was, in my eyes, not democratic or representative of the majority of students views on the matter due to the ridiculously small margin. Everyone who played a part in getting Grace ousted should be aware of the part that they have also played in depriving other students of welfare support. Whilst YUSU may insist that the decision will not affect the welfare of the students, it clearly will do: if there was sufficient welfare support within the union, then they wouldn't have needed Grace in the first place. Plus, as this removal is unprecedented, there really can be no guarantee of the subsequent quality of support. The students have shot themselves and their peers in the feet.

#35 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 6:01am

people say that 1440 votes were cast..

Votes for: 656
Votes against: 648

thats a total of 1304. Unless you count abstentions as votes, which would mean there were 1440 votes and that only 45.55*% of people supported the motion.

Just a thought, for all you budding political journalists.

#36 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 6:07am
  1. 34 i would love for you to expand on your theory that the decision is not democratic. you wouldn't be able to though, because you're talking shit.

i'm aware of the part YUSU have played in depriving students of welfare support by having the option of a vote of 'no confidence' in their constitution with no policy to what should happen if it actually occurred. i am sure if this policy was in place Grace would have lost the vote by a much larger margin. this kind of blackmail from the Grace campaign has probably been the most undemocratic part of the whole saga.

#37 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 6:10am

I bet Grace wishes she had 8 more friends

#38 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 6:40am

I think Grace is a great person and am really sad to see her go, but i voted for her to go because regardless of personality it was the right thing to happen.
Violence is unacceptable full stop. She simply should have know better and I find it really very sad she did not.

#39 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 6:49am

36. What do you mean, 'this kind of blackmail from the Grace campaign'? Do you mean that thinking of the students' welfare is 'undemocratic' somehow? How ridiculous. How could this issue have been discussed without bringing into it the potential consequences of such a motion in terms of welfare provisions for the students? The welfare of the students is surely the most important concern.

#40 Anonymous
Fri, 8th Feb 2008 6:58am

I think the reputation and standing of the Union and the right of Union members (that's all of us) to have our vote are both equally important concerns. It's not like we are all going to die or go mental because the Welfare Officer has gone. There are many other welfare resources on campus - counselling, college welfare representatives, tutors, provosts...

Showing 21 - 40 of 63 comments

Add Comment

You must log in to submit a comment.