23rd January
latest news: Anna's sweet and sticky pork buns

Comments by...

Latest Comment Articles...

Feminist Suffrage Parade in New York City, May 6, 1912.

Coming out

Thursday, 19th January 2012

Kate Bull is a feminist and proud.

Good Manners

Not my place to say, but…

Monday, 16th January 2012

Harriet Jean Evans takes a look at the social commentary of the past, and explains why she believes it just doesn't matter.

christmas

Advent Calendar Day 23

Friday, 23rd December 2011

Our anonymous blogger reflects on her attempts to have a student Christmas... and how she came to the conclusion that home-made is always best.

yusu logo

Save our Women's Officers

Wednesday, 30th November 2011

Gillian Love urges you to vote 'No' to the motion to replace Women's Committee with a 'Gender Equality Committee'.

More Comment Articles

york minster
Occupy Wall Street banner
Food Aid in Africa
Cenotaph
Latin Cross
morterboard and degree
Storming of Milbank
Facebook News Feed
Small not found

A fine, fine line

Banter
If only it were this harmless...
Sunday, 20th March 2011
Since coming to University, I have discovered the wonderful world of “banter”. And yes, it is wonderful – sometimes. Basically, a word indicating any kind of amusing talk, I relished the opportunity to offer quickfire responses to any quips given out by my friends and vice versa. It was fun, it was harmless. Yet as the phenomenon ages, there’s an ever-decreasing boundary between “banter” and just downright offensive.

So where did it all go wrong?

Essentially, the idea of “banter” is just to have a bit of fun among friends. Good-natured jibing between people who know each other and know the limits of how far they can go in such conversations, never hurt anyone. Last year, I’m pretty sure I used the word “banter” on innumerable occasions – along with “sport” (don’t ask), it was probably the word of Summer 2010.

And even when such jibing became increasingly stereotype-based, it was still funny. Because when the guy telling you to get back in the kitchen to make him a sandwich is a good friend, you know it’s all a joke and he doesn’t actually mean it. Likewise, when an ethnic friend makes a joke about his own ethnicity, you know it’s okay for you (and quite a few of your friends) to joke about it too – as long as people know their limits, there’s nothing to worry about, right?

But then something awkward (in my opinion) happened. The emergence of the LAD, whose “banter” is their greatest asset: and things have taken a negative turn. Association with the LAD phenomenon has not done the concept of “banter” any favours in a lot of people’s eyes. People who knew any self-professed LADs (and didn’t like what they knew) were suddenly reluctant to use the word “banter” anymore in referencing their, well, banter, with their friends. I dismissed all this, of course; despite the negative connotations given to the word by a few select idiots, the majority of people, (yes, even self-professed LADs) still used the word to mean a whole lot of fun that never hurt anyone and I agreed.

That was, until a week or so ago when I was on the receiving end of some relatively offensive, ill-timed and inappropriate “banter”.

Never in my life have I been called “darling” so many times. And “broad” as well – I mean, seriously, we don’t live in the 1950s any more guys. Never before have I imagined such a patronising tone of voice. And never before have I wanted to hit my computer so much.

You see, the problem with this “banter” was that it was over Facebook comments on a certain photograph. So, of course, as someone tried to point out, they could be being completely light-hearted with the misogynist attitudes. But that’s not the point. The point is, they could be being completely serious. Either way, I’m not going to let anyone call me “darling” like that. If you know that your comments could be misconstrued or misunderstood – simple, don’t leave them. Over Facebook you just can’t tell, so unless you wanted to cause offensive, any intelligent person just wouldn’t risk it. Likewise, these guys were complete strangers to me and my friend (who I had stepped in to defend). For all they knew we might have been bullied at school with misogynist “darlings”. We might know that we could never have children – and so the housewife and mother inferences in some of their comments could have really, really pissed us off. As it was, they were lucky, we just wrote them off as small-minded and chauvinistic idiots, but they don’t know that. And that’s what really did piss me off. Here were a couple of guys who knew nothing about who they were ribbing. And they clearly didn’t care if they insulted they just wanted a reaction. Okay, so I rose to it, but only because I think some people just need to learn: so it’s a free world and they can say what they like – it does not mean in any way I have to suck it up.

I was accused of not knowing the “meaning” of “banter”.

Trust me guys, I’m pretty sure I’ve thought about this far more than you’ve ever thought about anything. I know “banter” and I know offensive. And I know there’s a damn fine line between them

But that doesn’t make it okay to cross it.

Check out The Yorker's Twitter account for all the latest news Go to The Yorker's Fan Page on Facebook
#1 Anonymous
Sun, 20th Mar 2011 11:50pm

Social comment banter.

#2 Robin Ganderton
Sun, 27th Mar 2011 1:57pm

I hate it when I cause offensive :(

Add Comment

You must log in to submit a comment.