23rd January
latest news: Anna's sweet and sticky pork buns

Arts Sections

Music
Performing Arts
Film
Art and Literature
Arts Features and Multimedia
TV
Games
Original Work

Latest articles from this section

War Horse

War Horse

Tuesday, 17th January 2012

Stephen Puddicombe looks at Steven Spielberg's latest effort

We Have a Pope

We Have a Pope

Sunday, 15th January 2012

James Absolon explains how this Pope-themed film, despite its risky premise, works

The Artist

The Artist

Saturday, 14th January 2012

Stephen Puddicombe on why The Artist is such a special film.

The Iron Lady

The Iron Lady

Friday, 13th January 2012

Alex Pollard reviews Hollywood's biopic of the controversial Margaret Thatcher

More articles from this section

Sherlock Holmes 2
Girl with dragon tatttoo
Mission Impossible
Black Swan
The King's Speech
The Thing

The Thing

Wed, 21st Dec 11
Romantics Anonymous
hugo

Hugo

Mon, 19th Dec 11
New Years Eve

New Year's Eve

Sun, 18th Dec 11

The Expendables

The Expendables
Stallone and Statham
Thursday, 26th August 2010
Sylvester Stallone’s last films were nostalgic trips to rekindle the fading memories of his past glories. This achieved, he has called in a few favours to bring almost every major action star into a single film, and with enough pyrotechnics to wage a small war, he sets about recreating the entire overblown 80s action genre that made him a star.

However, Stallone’s cast is not all it’s cracked up to be. Most notably, despite featuring prominently on the film poster, Bruce Willis and Arnold Schwarzenegger only have largely pointless cameos and neither throw so much as a punch. Furthermore, and perhaps even more telling, was the refusal of Jean-Claude Van Damme to take part in the film on the grounds that he felt that the story was practically nonexistent. This reveals perhaps the movie’s biggest problem - considering what he’s starred in, if Van Damme complains about an action movie’s screenplay being bad then it must be impressively so - and indeed it is.

It attempts to include every single negative cliché of the genre, whilst lacking any good one-liners and taking itself far too seriously. Added to which, the central plot of mercenaries liberating (/blowing up) a small island proves less involving than that of your average video game, which is essentially what the film begins to feel like. This is particularly noticeable when the hopelessly inaccurate enemies (/weapon fodder) go to the extremes of wearing uniformed face paint to become the perfect featureless torrent of targets.

The film also has numerous other problems, notably Stallone’s direction. He edits his sequences far too quickly, believing that an extraordinarily high body count is enough to make up for not being able to make sense of the carnage. This is particularly noticeable in a car chase that becomes nearly impossible to follow, although it has to be admitted that the sheer level of carnage displayed on screen cannot help but ingratiate itself upon the viewer and its end battle is impressive in terms of destruction if nothing else. This is the film’s one vague success and it is what makes it watchable and admittedly at times even a little enjoyable. Yet as soon as these scenes end the biggest problems start with the non-violent scenes being primarily made up of Jason Statham’s character complaining his girlfriend has left him and Jet Li arguing he needs a pay increase and supposedly humorous comments being made about his height. Indeed, the only character who ever caught my attention was Dolph Lundgren’s psychotic Gunner whose character as scripted makes little sense and is underused in this film.

Although enjoyable at odd moments, The Expendables feels more than a little disappointing, and considering its cast, you cannot help but think they could have created something far superior, rather than a simple excuse to kill extras. Stallone’s attempt to recreate his glory days shows only that he is far from the action star he used to be and that as a director has learnt little since the abomination that was Staying Alive.

Check out The Yorker's Twitter account for all the latest news Go to The Yorker's Fan Page on Facebook
#1 James Hodgson
Fri, 27th Aug 2010 1:56am

I agree. The best action films have strong character narratives, like the original Die Hard and Rambo. If you don't care whether the good guy lives or dies, you may as well be playing a computer game. Plus I couldn't tell whether the whole 'liberate the country by apparently killing everything in sight' mission was supposed to be stupidly ironic or depressingly sincere.

#2 James Arden
Sun, 29th Aug 2010 11:59pm
  • spoiler* When Gunner is revealed to still be alive at the end and friends with them all once again, it ruined any credible ending the film could have possibly had.

Add Comment

You must log in to submit a comment.