23rd January
latest news: Anna's sweet and sticky pork buns

Arts Sections

Music
Performing Arts
Film
Art and Literature
Arts Features and Multimedia
TV
Games
Original Work

Latest articles from this section

Gabriel Macht

Suits: 'Pilot'

Thursday, 19th January 2012

Jasmine Sahu is well suited with this new American drama exclusive to Dave.

Call the Midwife

Call the Midwife

Thursday, 19th January 2012

Lois Cameron explains why this series is much more than your average cosy period drama.

Sherlock: The Reichenbach Fall

Sherlock: 'The Reichenbach Fall'

Tuesday, 17th January 2012

The last episode of this series sees Sherlock and Moriarty attempt to solve the final problem with devastating consequences.

Being Human

Can Being Human survive past Series 4?

Saturday, 14th January 2012

With major cast changes afoot, Jacob Martin ponders whether Being Human can live up to its own scarily high standard.

More articles from this section

Sherlock: The Hounds of Baskerville
Public Enemies
York Minster

Eternal Law

Sat, 7th Jan 12
Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler
Great Expectations
Merlin
Rev
Bear Grylls and Miranda Hart
Doctor Who - The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe

Silent Witness: implausible? So what?

Silent Witness
Thursday, 3rd February 2011

It has been said of Silent Witness that its premise is fairly implausible. The idea that forensic pathologists could take an active part in a murder investigation, accompany detectives in interviewing suspects and even investigate by themselves is pretty far-fetched. However, as a seasoned crime-drama viewer, I know that plausibility is not the most vital element of a programme such as this - just look at Midsommer Murders. Now admittedly series 14 did take things a little far, with Harry being shot in the face and set on fire and then managing to come back to life, kill a pimp, expose corrupt diplomats, take on the mafia, and deliver a baby all in one day. Things did get a little out of control.

The thing is, I don’t care. Despite the improbable storylines and implausibly attractive and well-adjusted pathologists, the fact that Silent Witness is so well executed means that even fourteen series on, it is still one of the best crime-dramas on TV. Yes Nikki wears stilettos in the lab while slicing and dicing, but the acting is good, the characters and their relationships are well written and have evolved over time, with love interests that keep us hoping as much as any soap, and there are plenty of gory scenes of sawing through skulls and investigating stomach contents to relish from the comfort of the sofa. Besides, its American counterpart CSI redefines implausibility and no one cares. The fact is that without the beautiful people, gung-ho investigations and poetic license with the facts, I would have spent my Tuesday evenings watching dead people being chopped up for an hour and that would have been no fun at all.

Series fourteen began with a psychiatrist who is crazier than his patients. The murderer turns out to be his daughter who is even crazier than he is. Even Nikki goes a bit mental. This episode did a great job manipulating the viewer’s imagination and gave a great sense of characters’ troubled minds with its twisty-turny plot and confused editing. We moved on to an investigation set on wild moors and peat bogs, with well-preserved bodies being poked and prodded with great enthusiasm and distinctly off country-types who said things like ‘Arrr’. Episode three’s look at army secrecy covered some well-trodden ground with great aplomb while the aforementioned brilliantly sill Hungarian episode also featured one of the best cliff-hangers I’ve seen in a long time. I had a similarly enthusiastic reaction to the final episode, which clearly took a lot of inspiration from The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, and carried it off very well. I’ve never quite trusted the Dutch - I think it’s the accent or possibly that they seem overly friendly - and this episode did not help reconcile me to what is no doubt a very trustworthy nation.

From the moment the really creepy opening credits began this series all the way through many a grisly murder to the very last scene of Leo‘s MBE and a thinly veiled Emilia Fox pregnancy, Silent Witness kept me coming back for more, and more is still what I want.

Check out The Yorker's Twitter account for all the latest news Go to The Yorker's Fan Page on Facebook

Add Comment

You must log in to submit a comment.