23rd January
latest news: Anna's sweet and sticky pork buns

Blog Sections

That Girl
Roxy

Latest blog entries

candle

The Advent Calendar: Day 3

Sunday, 4th December 2011

That Girl from Derwent dwells on the value of religion this Christmas.

Student reading

A dividing line

Sunday, 6th November 2011

That Girl from Derwent has learned a few more things about prejudice since moving up North.

Stamp out racism

There's no need to be racist

Monday, 31st October 2011

That Girl From Derwent reckons if you're going to be offensive, you should find a better reason.

Fuck off, Amerika

The problem of "swearing"

Tuesday, 25th October 2011

That Girl from Derwent considers why it is that some words have wider implications than others.

More blog entries

Coots at York Uni
york minster
SlutWalk2
Art class
Easter eggs
A pile of open books
Naughty Food
Cow
chess

Why is everything so tragic?

A pile of open books
Tragic life stories have become an industry
Friday, 6th February 2009
I was recently looking through the books in WH Smith, heading towards the cookery section (not for me, you understand, as I can’t cook, but for a present). On the way there I passed a new section whose title made me cringe. It was called ‘Tragic Life Stories’. Not only does this sound like a bestsellers list compiled by the Daily Mail, but it’s certainly not subtle.

I was aware of titles such as A Child Called It, but now books such as these have grown into a genre, demanding their own section in high street book stores. A glance over the titles and blurbs of the other books - mostly tales of abusive childhoods - didn’t reassure me that they would offer anything different.

Now, I understand that I could come across as being incredibly callous and insensitive in trying to make my point, so let me say this: I fully comprehend the cathartic nature of writing down one’s own problems and thus confronting them (I’m writing a blog, that’s exactly what I’m doing).

But the fact that these ‘Tragic Life Stories’ have now become an industry, a viable market that publishers can tap into, means that this new genre seems almost exploitative. The increasing number of these books necessitates competition, which means that these authors are vying with each other, albeit indirectly, to get you to read their harrowing life stories.

Quote The fact that these ‘Tragic Life Stories’ have now become an industry means that this new genre seems almost exploitative. Quote

And that’s another thing that puzzles me – the demand for these books. There must be people who read them, otherwise they would not be in circulation. But surely one would not want to read more than one or two of these stories? By the end of book two you would be emotionally exhausted and depressed.

I can perhaps understand reading titles such as A Child Called It, which has been singled out by critics and the public, but to me reading anymore doesn’t seem worth it. So although I won’t fail to offer my sympathies to anyone who needs it, I won’t be reading their book.

Check out The Yorker's Twitter account for all the latest news Go to The Yorker's Fan Page on Facebook

Add Comment

You must log in to submit a comment.